Compare Bandcamp Playlist Tools
A detailed comparison of every way to create and share Bandcamp playlists: Indie Crates, BNDCMPR, Buy Music Club, and Bandcamp's native feature.
Quick Summary
Indie Crates
Best all-around option
Web-based, embeddable, community features, actively developed, free.
BNDCMPR
Simple and functional
Web-based and embeddable, but no community features or recent updates.
Buy Music Club
Discovery-focused
Great for music discovery and purchase links, less focused on playlist playback.
Bandcamp Native
Limited use case
Mobile app only, purchased music only, no embedding.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Indie Crates | BNDCMPR | Buy Music Club | Bandcamp Native |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform & Access | ||||
| Web-based | Yes | Yes | Yes | No (mobile app only) |
| Mobile app | No (web works on mobile) | No | No | Yes (required) |
| Account required to create | Yes (free) | No | Yes (free) | Yes (Bandcamp account) |
| Account required to listen | No | No | No | Yes |
| Playlist Creation | ||||
| Any Bandcamp music | Yes | Yes | Yes | No (purchased only) |
| Unlimited playlists | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Auto-fetch metadata | Yes | Basic | Yes | Yes |
| Drag-and-drop reordering | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Sharing & Embedding | ||||
| Shareable links | Yes | Yes | Yes | App-only sharing |
| Embeddable player | Yes | Yes | Basic | No |
| Custom embed options | Yes | No | No | No |
| Community & Discovery | ||||
| User profiles | Yes | No | Yes | Basic |
| Browse other playlists | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Follow curators | Coming soon | No | Yes | No |
| Favorite playlists | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Platform Health | ||||
| Active development | Yes | No | Limited | Yes |
| Last updated | 2025 | ~2020 | ~2023 | Ongoing |
| Free | Yes (forever) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Detailed Tool Reviews
Indie Crates
Indie Crates is the most feature-complete option for creating Bandcamp playlists. It combines the simplicity of BNDCMPR with community features inspired by Buy Music Club, plus active development that ensures compatibility and new features.
Best for: Music bloggers, curators who want profiles, anyone needing embeddable playlists.
Strengths:
- Full-featured embeddable player
- User profiles and community discovery
- Active development with regular updates
- Clean, modern interface
Limitations:
- Requires account to create (not to listen)
- No mobile app (web works on mobile)
BNDCMPR
bndcmpr.co
BNDCMPR is the original third-party Bandcamp playlist tool. It's simple and effective—paste URLs, get a shareable playlist. However, it hasn't been updated in years and lacks community features.
Best for: Quick, anonymous playlist creation without needing an account.
Strengths:
- No account required
- Simple, fast interface
- Reliable embeds
Limitations:
- No user profiles or community
- No recent updates or new features
- Basic metadata fetching
Buy Music Club
buymusic.club
Buy Music Club focuses on music discovery and supporting artists through purchases. It's less about playlist playback and more about curated lists with direct purchase links.
Best for: Music discovery, supporting artist sales, genre-focused curation.
Strengths:
- Strong community and discovery features
- Direct purchase links for every track
- Genre categorization
Limitations:
- Less focused on playlist playback
- Embed options are basic
- Limited development activity
Bandcamp Native Playlists
bandcamp.com (mobile app)
Bandcamp's official playlist feature exists but with significant limitations. It only works in the mobile app and only with music you've purchased.
Best for: Organizing your personal Bandcamp collection on mobile.
Strengths:
- Official Bandcamp feature
- Integrated with your purchases
- High-quality streaming
Limitations:
- Mobile app only—no web access
- Purchased music only
- No embedding or public sharing
- Can't curate music you don't own
Use Case Recommendations
🎵 Music Bloggers
Recommended: Indie Crates
Embeddable players work perfectly in blog posts. Create a playlist for your review and embed it directly in your article.
📧 Newsletter Curators
Recommended: Indie Crates
Share playlist links in your newsletter, or embed players in HTML newsletters.
🎤 Artists
Recommended: Indie Crates
Create "if you like my music, check out these artists" playlists. Embed on your website to keep fans engaged.
🛒 Buyers
Recommended: Buy Music Club
If your goal is to find new music to purchase, Buy Music Club's direct purchase links are helpful.
⚡ Quick Share
Recommended: BNDCMPR
Need to share a quick playlist without creating an account? BNDCMPR works instantly.
📱 Personal Collection
Recommended: Bandcamp Native
If you just want to organize music you've already purchased on mobile, Bandcamp's native feature works fine.
Try Indie Crates Free
Join 47 music curators who have created 100 crates.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between Indie Crates and BNDCMPR?
Both are free Bandcamp playlist makers, but Indie Crates adds user profiles, community discovery features, and is actively developed. BNDCMPR is simpler but hasn't been updated in years. Both offer embeddable players and shareable links.
Is Buy Music Club better than Indie Crates?
They serve different purposes. Buy Music Club focuses on music discovery through lists with purchase links. Indie Crates focuses on creating embeddable playlists with a player interface. Both have community features, but Indie Crates offers better embed options for blogs and websites.
Why not just use Bandcamp's native playlists?
Bandcamp's native playlist feature only works in their mobile app and only with music you've purchased. If you want to create web-based playlists with any Bandcamp music, or embed them on your website, you need a third-party tool like Indie Crates.
Which Bandcamp playlist tool is best for bloggers?
Indie Crates is ideal for bloggers because it offers embeddable players that work great in articles and newsletters. You can create a curated playlist and embed it directly in your blog post, allowing readers to listen without leaving your site.
